Are Toned Coins Worth More?


It’s important knowledge to have, as attractive natural toning can make a coin worth exponentially more, while artificial toning can completely ruin a coin’s collectible value.

How do you tell if a coin is artificially toned?

Signs that a Coin Has Been Artificially Toned

  1. Hairline scratches on the coin’s surface can indicate cleaning with an abrasive chemical or brush.
  2. A dark brown or bluish hue often comes from chemical toning.
  3. Spots often appear on an artificially toned coin’s surface if the chemical reacts unevenly.

Are toned Morgans worth more?

It is certainly possible for an MS63 toned Morgan to be worth more than an MS67 Morgan because of color, but when comparing a monster toned MS63 or MS64 Morgan to a monster toned MS67 or MS68, the grade can make a massive difference in value.

Why is my silver coin turning black?

Silver becomes black because of hydrogen sulfide (sulfur), a substance that occurs in the air. When silver comes into contact with it, a chemical reaction takes place and a black layer is formed. … Besides that, the natural oils that your skin produces can also react to your silver jewelry.

How do you tell if a coin has been cleaned?

A cleaned coin will have a dull, bright look – one that on a well-circulated coin would seem unnatural. Old pennies that have been worn should not look bright orange and have flashy surfaces. Old, worn pennies should be medium to dark brown in color and have virtually no reflectivity on the surface at all.

Why does my silver coin look gold?

Toning is a term that describes the discoloration or light patina that forms on the surface of coins due to oxygen and chemicals in the air acting on the metal. This oxidation can result in a variety and level of toning and also depends on the properties of the metal – silver, gold, copper, nickel, etc.

Should I polish old coins?

In general, old coins should not be cleaned. While you might think that getting all the years of dirt and grime off a coin would make it more valuable, the opposite is actually true! By cleaning a coin, you may actually damage it and decrease its value.

Why do pennies turn black?

When oxygen binds with copper, they form a new molecule known as copper oxide. Copper oxide is brownish or sometimes black in color (depending on other things in the penny’s environment). This is why most pennies you see look dirty or tarnished—it’s not actually dirt but copper oxide that makes them look so dull.

How do you safely clean old coins?

Follow These Steps:

  1. In a jar, combine one cup vinegar (or lemon juice) and 1 tablespoon salt. …
  2. Pour the solution into the plastic container. …
  3. Add the coins in a single layer, so none of the coins are touching. …
  4. When you remove the coins and wipe them with a cloth or paper towel, they should look shiny.

Can you remove toning from coins?

Removing Toning or Tarnish

We would always to prefer, and recommend, to leave most coins as they are, and refrain from cleaning them. … Mostly we try to leave toning where when it looks natural and enhances the appearance of a coin. Remember that the toning actually helps to prevent further toning.


How many 1943 steel pennies are left?

Nearly all circulating pennies at that time were struck in zinc–coated steel because copper and nickel were needed for the Allied war effort. Approximately 40 1943 copper–alloy cents are known to remain in existence.

What does toned mean in coin collecting?

Toning on a coin is the change of colour brought about through oxidization, which forms a thin layer of tarnish on the metal’s surface. Coin toning can vary in aesthetics, and thus can alternately add or detract from a coin’s value. Coins with unusual toning colours or patterns tend to be valued by coin collectors.

Can you clean coins without losing value?

It is best not to clean rare coins as removing the patina can significantly reduce the value of them. For this reason, most coin hobbyists almost never clean their coins. In fact, 99% of coins do not increase in value after you clean them, but many will be greatly devalued.

Why did my silver coin turn yellow?

Tarnish is the discolouration that forms on the surface of coins due to a chemical reaction that naturally occurs when the silver comes into contact with humidity and chemicals in the air.

Are tarnished silver coins worth less?

Does Silver Tarnish Affect the Silver Value? With lower premium items such as silver rounds and silver bars, tarnishing really doesn’t have an impact on the value of these items. … When it comes to numismatic items, tarnishing starts to have more of an effect on the price.

How do I tone my hair silver?

Toners for Silver Hair

To achieve silver or grey hair, you want to tone your hair with a purple based toner, such as the Wella T18 Lightest Ash Blonde toner. Since your hair will be quite damaged at this point, you should use it with a 10 volume developer instead of 20 unless your hair pulls really warm.

How do you artificially age a coin?

  1. Add 1 part bleach to 1 part water directly into the plastic bowl. Place your coins into the mixture and set aside for one hour. …
  2. Remove the coins from the bleach and rinse with water. Pat dry with a towel or air dry the coins.
  3. Rub the emery board over the sides, front and back of the coin.

Should you clean wheat pennies?

Removing corrosion from foreign coins, Morgan dollars, wheat pennies, and other valuables is a delicate, risky proposition. Again, we do not recommend cleaning rare coins if you are looking to sell them since cleaning such precious items devalues them.

Why are cleaned coins worth less?

This is because anything that touches a coin has the potential to damage it at the microscopic level. The more abrasive a cleaner is used to clean the coin, the more likely it is to remove the upper surface of the coin – damage that can never be undone.

Can a cleaned coin be restored?

Original Surfaces Can Never Be Restored

The technical term that numismatists used to refer to the shine that new coins have is called mint luster. … The exception to the rule of never cleaning your coins is ancient coins that are at least 1,000 years old.