What Happens If You Kill Astrid In The Shack?


After killing Grelod, go to sleep – you will be kidnapped by Astrid and then you have a choice: either kill any of the prisoners if you want to join the brotherhood or kill Astrid if you want to destroy it. Visiting the Sanctuary before that shouldn’t influence the outcome.

Can you kill Astrid when you first meet her?

She asks to be killed with her Blade of Woe, but she can be killed with any weapon. After Astrid’s death, the Dragonborn and the remaining assassins, including Nazir and Babette, move to the Dawnstar Sanctuary, where Cicero fled and can still be found if he was spared.

Should I kill Cicero or Astrid?

Though shell not kill the Dark Brotherhood or it’s members. She kills everyone and almost kills you and Cicero. The punishment for breaking the Tenets according to Sithis in Oblivion is expulsion from the Dark Brotherhood or death. This is why you must kill her Cicero is the head of the Dark Brotherhood not her.

Is it worth killing Cicero?

Since you can pickpocket him and receive higher grade gear at the Dawnstar Sanctuary, it is really not lucrative to kill him. If you have completed the quest line for the Dark Brotherhood, and Cicerio is still alive at that point, he will indeed become a Follower.

Can you marry Cicero?

This mod lets you marry Cicero after you finish the Dark Brotherhood questline. … 2.0: You can go through the marriage ceremony with him. He will attend the marriage ceremony and recieve a Bond of Matrimony.

Which person do I kill for Astrid?

Killing the Khajiit may ease the consciences of some, but for others there is always the option of killing Astrid. Kill Astrid and you will find the key to escape the shack on her body, the quest for the Dark Brotherhood will come up as failed…

Can I destroy the thieves guild?

You can’t kill any of them. You might deal enough damage to bring them to their knees, but that’s it. They won’t die.

Who is Astrid married to Skyrim?

Astrid is the leader of the Dark Brotherhood in Skyrim. She resides in the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary, near Falkreath. Married to Arnbjorn, a fellow Dark Brotherhood assassin, she holds the responsibility of finding new recruits in the Night Mother’s absence.

Is joining the Dark Brotherhood worth it oblivion?

The Dark Brotherhood quests are arguably the best quests in the game, which lead to a awesome plot twist and great ending. The benefits of completing the DB quests, like all the sidequests arcs, are lame, but it’s worth it just for some of the best story in Oblivion.

Should I kill Amaund Motierre?

Hail Sithis!

, which is located in an urn in the original chamber that Motierre and Rexus were in. … After collecting the reward, the Dragonborn has the option to kill Motierre. Doing so gives the advantage of collecting a few rare gems from his corpse, as well as possibly receiving an inheritance from him.

How do you end the Dark Brotherhood forever?

Nope, never ends. It’s a radiant quest. You’ll be told to go to one side of the map to get a measly amount of gold, then be told to go to the other side of the map to kill a randomly generated and unnamed NPC (i.e. “beautiful barbarian”).

What is the hardest thing to kill in Skyrim?

But the hardest boss fights in Skyrim aren’t the only dangers players face.

  • 2 Werewolf Vargr.
  • 3 Nightmaster Vampire. …
  • 4 Vulthuryol – The Blackreach Dragon. …
  • 5 Arch Mages – No, Not That Kind. …
  • 6 Falmer Warmonger – Dangers In The Dark. …
  • 7 Trolls – The Worst Thing Below Level 35. …
  • 8 Dragon Priest – Gotta Collect ‘Em All. …

Is destroying the Dark Brotherhood worth it?

Can you wipe them out at any point after joining, or are they marked as essential? Then don’t destroy them. The only benefit is that if you’re not going to do the questline, you won’t get all those assassins chasing you around Skyrim. Other than that, it’s a waste of a good faction questline.

Can you still destroy the Dark Brotherhood after joining?

Nope. The moment you talk to astrid after killing any of the hostages, the DB npcs become essential.

Are the Thieves Guild evil?

The guild is actually a necessary evil to the land. They have strict rules of not killing, protect the poor and beggars and have a flexbility of action that the ‘official governent force’ have not.

Can you keep the skeleton key?

The Skeleton Key can be used like a regular lockpick and can be kept indefinitely, provided it’s never returned to the Twilight Sepulcher, during the mission “Darkness Returns.” In addition, the Lockpicking skill will still increase when a lock is opened (removed in patch 1.4, back by 1.9).

What happens if you dont join the Thieves Guild?

You don’t even necessarily have to join. Through a speech check, you can convince Brynjolf that your (The Dragonborn’s) business, is more important than his. Thereby bypassing the initiation into the guild. Or you can just talk to Keerava at the Bee and Barb.

Should I kill Astrid or join the Dark Brotherhood?

If you kill Astrid, you get a quest that involves destroying the rest of the Dark Brotherhood. If you kill any or all of the contracts, you will get a quest to join the Dark Brotherhood. Pick whichever sounds like more fun, or whatever your character’s morality allows.

Is Astrid bad Skyrim?

Leader of the infamous Dark Brotherhood assassins’ guild, Astrid isn’t only evil because of how she absolutely delights in killing people, but also because she’s fundamentally self-serving despite pretending to be the mother and leader of her guild.

Does killing Cicero make a difference?

Killing Cicero grants you access to his unique outfit and benefits, but loses on a pretty unique follower. He’s the ideal stealth follower, and cares not for crimes. He can be quite amusing to those who liked the Annoying Fan from Oblivion.

What happens if I spare Cicero?

Cicero is found lying on the ground injured. … It should be noted that if Cicero is spared in this quest he will become an available follower for the Dragonborn. If he is killed, his body can be looted for his outfit (the Jester’s Outfit on the table at the entrance is less powerful), some gold and a leveled dagger.

Can you get married to Cicero in Skyrim?

You cannot marry Cicero in skyrim, because his loyalty to the Night Mother.